Dan walks by – a tall figure in a black coat. Black, slightly curly hair is all long enough to kiss his jaw. A neatly trimmed beard paints his face with the bold strokes of an ink-dripped brush. Although his skin is tan, one can see a paleness swimming underneath, wistfully waiting to break to the surface, and spread, to cover it.
He walked past on the far side of the patio, but as he walked he scanned the tables, and when he found Steve he flashed him a smile just before he went into the front doors of the coffee shop. Coming out of the shop by the side door to the patio about three minutes later with a medium-sized to go cup in his hand, he quickly scanned the patio again, then threw Steve a brief wave and tramped over to Steve’s table.”Hey,” he said. Steve saw that though he though at first that all his clothes were black, they were really several colors, but all dark. They were also slightly ill-fitting, and a bit worn. Gray dockers, black sneakers over white socks, a dark brown sweatshirt and a loosely hanging black trench coat. Although from the distant glimpse Steve had as he walkef into the coffee shop he looked to be dressed formally, Steve saw now that this was nowhere near so. Dan dressed like a student.
Plopped down in the chair opposite Steve, Dan glanced left and right. “Nice day, huh?” A breeze stirred the open flaps of his coat and tumbled the steam rising off of his coffee. A small laugh chuffed out his nose. “Anyway I like it. I always liked cool weather.” He then turned his head to look Steve full in the face and beemed. “So. Howya been?”
Steve’s face elongated in appraisal. “I been alright. And you?”
“Been great. Somebody told me you’ve been at the same job since graduation? How’s that going? You must like it, I guess.”
“It’s all right. I mean, it’s been good, but I- I’ll probably going to be looking to make a change pretty soon.”
“Really?” Dan’s face showed actual, real interest. He leanaed forward and put his elbows on the table and his shoulders in a half shrug. “What’s the problem? Things turn bad?”
“No, not really.” Steve shrugged with his mouth. “I guess I just feel that I could be doing more, but I don’t see the opportunities where I’m at right now. I don’t want to be stuck in the same place forever – I mean, I wouldn’t mind being at one company a long time, if I felt I was being challenged, and I had opportunities to do a variety of things. But as it stands right now, I don’t think I’m going to have those opportunities where I am.”
Dan smiled in amusement. “Ambition.”
“Well yeah. Ambition, and boredom.”
Dan’s lower lip pushed up against his upper lip. “I see.” He nodded.
Steve closed his eyes briefly, then shook his head. “Anyway. And you? Nobody’s told me anything about you. I mean, I haven’t heard anything about you for a long time. What have you been doing? Do your parents know where you are? Have you been in touch with your parents?” Steve felt the right to pry that far. The two of them had been close.
There was some hesitancy, but Dan kept his gaze full on Steve’s face. “Yeah. Yes I have.” He didn’t drop his smile, but it didn’t look as natural as a moment before.
“How are they, by the way.”
“They’re great. They’re good. Thanks for asking.”
“And your sister? How’s she doing?”
Dan suddenly and for an instant looked bored, tired, and cross. Then it was gone. Steve thought he saw the skin of Dan’s face lift slightly, like a theater curtain. “Rebecca? Doin’ great. She’s going to graduate from college this spring.”
Steve’s eyebrows went up, once again elongating half of his face. “Oh? Great. That’s great.” His eyebrows came back down. “So, you. What have you been doing again?”
“Well…” Dan leaned back in his chair. He put his left hand on the chair’s arm rest and with his right he picked up his cup of coffee and held it in front of his chest, poised to drink when ready. “Lots of things.
“When I left school I had gone to visit a commune that one of my professors was connected with. I stayed there a while, but it wasn’t really what I was into. Then I rode the rails for a while, through Montana and Wyoming – it felt like I did that a lot longer than I actually did. Let’s see… I worked part of a season picking grapes with some migrant workers. Then I moved back to the coast, to my old college neighborhood. I moved into a co-op and was working for kind of an underground newspaper there. I stayed in touch with that professor. He tells me I could probably go back to school there if I wanted.”
“Wow. You’ve done a lot of stuff.” Dan just shrugged and tightened one corner of his lips. “I would love to run across your memories of some of that stuff during a plug in session.” Steve was thinking back to their childhood attempts to pick up each other’s specific memories.
Dan’s eyes quickly and wariy looked at Steve from beneath their brows. “Yeah, well.” Dan’s speech slowed. “I don’t think there’s much chance of that.”
“Oh? Why do you say that?” Again with the eyebrows going up, stretching out the upper half of his face.
“I haven’t plugged in since I left college.”
“What?” Steve went blank. He forgot where he was for a moment. The air around him seemed to go white for a moment. A second later, he could remember it not going white and he could also remember it going white. “You’re, you… What? what was that?”
“I haven’t plugged in to a memory server, in fact I haven’t even visited a server farm, since I left college three years ago.”
“How did you do that?”
“What do you mean how did I do that? It’s not that I did something. I didn’t do something. I didn’t go into a server farm and plug in to one of the memory bank machines.”
“Okay…”, said Steve, in a tone that he would have used in granting, for the sake of argument, that aliens controlled the government. “But.” He sighed in exasperation, abandoning whatever he had just tried to grant. “But how can you live without plugging in?”
“Steve, people lived for thousands of years without plugging in. Thousands. Of years.”
“Yeah, okay – but they didn’t live in this society. I don’t see how you can live in this society without plugging in. But I guess you’re not living in this society, are you?”
“Oh come on. I’m sitting here drinking coffee with you. Of course I live in this society. Think about it. What about this society actually requires you to plug in? Nothing. When, why do you ever really need to plug in?”
“We had to plug in in high school, a certain number of times a week.”
“Well, we were expected to. I don’t remember any formal sanction procedures around it. And anyway, that was for four years, several years ago now. How about today. In your job, for example. Why would you need to plug in to function.”
Steve paused. “Okay. I can’t… think of any time when it’s explicitly required, but implicitly? I mean, it’s assumed in virtually every social interaction. I assumed it at the beginning of this conversation. Do you admit that you don’t plug in every time the subject of plugging in comes up, as you did to me? I assume anyone else’s reaction would be like mine, or worse.”
“No, I don’t admit it aevery time it comes up.”
“So you lie.”
“I remain silent. Don’t think you’re going to drag me into some Ethics 101 discussion of whether it is a requirement for society not to lie.”
“You conceal.”
“Of ocurse I conceal. Everyone conceals something. Did you openly discuss with your parents all the times you smoked pot in college?”
“Hmmmm, no. But this type of transgression seems more fundamental to me somehow.”
“Transgression? Smoking pot is more of a transgression than not pluggin in. Smoking pot is actually illegal. There’s no law outlining a punishment for refusing to plug in.”
For a moment Steve thought, “There should be.” but immediately saw that as repulsive. “Alright, setting aside whether or not it’s sanctioned, in either sense of the word – why would you want to go without plugging in?”
Dan smiled. “Ah. Exactly where I wanted to lead the conversation. Thank you.”
“Oh?” Steve’s eyebrows went up again, but only about halfway this time. It gave him a lowering expression.
“Yeah,” said Dan. “I want to try to convince you to at least try living without plugging in.”
“What?” Steve’s eyebrows slammed back down to an expression of skeptical shock. “Why would I want to do that?”
“Two words: freedom and individuality.”
“That doesn’t make any fucking sense. There’s nothing about plugging in that infringes on my individuality, and certainly not on my freedom, either.”
“I disagree. And to prove you wrong, I will just ask you why you would want to plug in.”
“Why would I want to plug in? You want me to recite all of the reasons, that we’ve known since we were children, that should have been reiterated over and over during the course of anyone’s life?”
“Why have we known them since childhood? Not because we discovered them, but because they were told to us. Reiterated because they were drilled into us.”
“No. Most if not all benefits are self-evident – if not through direct experience, some of the social benefits can be found by a careful observer.”
“Effects can be experienced, yes; benefits must be judged. I would not call these effects benefits. But I am jumping ahead of myself a little. To answer your question, no, I don’t expect you to recite all of the alleged benefits – just a few will do for argument.”
“Well ok. How about improved memory, to take the most obvious. Do you really not remember high school? Do you not remember the academic competitions where we got our asses handed to us by the teams from private schools, who plugged in together every day?”
One thing I forgot to put in was Dan’s criticism of the improved memory claim – .Dan closed his eyes breifly as he nodded. “I remember. But I don’t think that it’s been proves that plugging in actually imporvesmemory – I think rather that people are just given a lot more crap to remember. But I’m sorry, I asked you to humor me. Please continue.”
“Okay. The other obvious benefit I’m guessing you want me to state is increased empathy. This benefit, if not felt directly by one person, can be observed over time in a group of people.”
“OK, thank you for humoring me. As I said, I would not call these benefits. I would call them effects. Whether or not they are benefits is a value judgement.”
“You don’t think they are good in and of themselves, huh? Well what is the Good then, my dear Socrates? Individuality and Freedom, I suppose?”
“Touche. I didn’t want to go that deep with my argument. But I will say that as my own value judgement, individuality and freedom are more important than improved memory or even improved empathy.”
“So you’re saying that given the choice you’d like enhanced individuality rather than enhanced empathy.”
“You’ve taken the most extreme opposition possible among the two pairs, but all right. I don’t think the choice is between improving your individuality and improving your empathy. It’s between leaving both alone on the one hand, and on the other increasing your empathy while decreasing your individuality. And I believe that decreasing your individuality decreases your freedom, which is not worth enhancing any other positive. Freedom is more the Good than empathy or anything else.”
“First of all, as you said before, what is a benefit and what is not, especially in relation or comparison to other effects, is a value judgement. Second of all, as regards freedom, am I not choosing to plug in? If I think that more empathy is good, even at the cost of some of my individuality, am I not excersicing the freedom that you seem so knock-kneed worried that I’m losing?”
“If you were able to choose whether or not to start plugging in I might agree with you. But everyone starts plugging in as children, at the direction of others. However well-intentioned that may be, there is little freedom in it.
“As well, it’s like an addictive drug. You may be free at the outset to choose whether or not to start taking it – though even that may not be completely true, because without having experienced it at least once you necessarily do not have all the pertinent information. And without all the pertinent information, how can you really make a free choice? But even granting that you freely make the choice to try it, the experience changes you such that any subsequent choices you make to use it cannot be said to be freely made.”
“You think that plugging in changes a person in such a way that they are compelled to plug in again.”
“I believe so. Yes.”
“Exactly how does that happen.”
“I don’t have the exact mechanism in my head. I have heard a few theories – some of which I didn’t understand, others that I thought were wrong. But I have an intuition that it is so, an intuition that I trust.”
“Okay. Finally, if plugging in deprives a person of the freedom to choose not to plug in, then how is it that you have managed to stop plugging in? And what kind of sense does it make for you to try to convince me to choose not to plug in, if I in fact have no choice in the matter? Isn’t it futile?”
“I had feared it might be.”